PDA

View Full Version : Product review: GFS Brooklyn


WireNWood
04-20-2006, 06:42 PM
A couple of months ago I threw out a lowball bid on a mixed lot of pickups on eBay, and won. Among them was a brand new unopened GFS Brooklyn, a big single-coil pickup in a 'bucker box.

http://us.st11.yimg.com/store1.yimg.com/I/yhst-50206111187217_1888_8145257


This model has 2 versions, one claimed to have a "DeArmond vibe" and the other with an extra word added: "raunchy DeArmond vibe". To the best of my ability to determine, I had in my hand the 'raunchy' one for bridge position. Eventually I sent to Guitarfetish and purchased a neck pickup to go with it. Unfortunately my eBay purchase was gold and white and currently this model is only available in chrome and white, so although they match inside they don't quite match on the outside.


Many weeks have elapsed with these pickups just waiting to participate in one of my Dr. Frankenaxe moments. That moment came today.

I had taken the Bill Lawrence (handwound, no finer pickup in the world) 'buckers outta my Ibanez Jet King in order to put them in my PRS-style axe when it arrives from Rondo. That left me with a expendable/experimental/beater/labratory-rat guitar hanging on the wall with 2 gaping holes needing 'buckerage.

Don't misunderstand about the Jet King - it is really a good guitar. Bolt-on, alder, T-O-M, string-through. It has a sweet (if plain) neck & board and with the L500 it'll sustain all day. However, the low purchase price and Fender-like ease of modification have fated it to forever be the victim of my evil machinations. Suddenly in my mind today I saw the 'Nez hanging there needing pups and I rememberd the Brooklyns waiting for a home. Ka-CHING.

So, I soldered 'em in. Two-conductor wiring - they are genuinely single coil pickups. Installation was simple as could be. Volpot...hmmmm... a too-fiddy or a fiver? Prolly should be a 250K but there's a fiver already there, so to hell with it. If they're too bright I'll put the 250 in later. Unfortunately, the guitar looks a little funny because one pup is chrome-n-white while the other is gold-n-white. (Abbey........somebody...) Ah, well... it wasn't pretty anyway.

http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b11/wirenwood/jet.jpg


I string 'er up & tune, then get ready for a critical listen. I sit in my chair facing the wall of amps, with my pedalboard before me. I turn on four amps. But first, here is what Guitar Fetish says about these pups:

*****************************

"GFS Retrotron series combine the vintage looks and tonality of the best classic pickups with modern levels of gain, sustain and noise resistance.

The Retrotron "Brooklyn" pickups give you that classic Dearmond feel- big, open and airy, but with a tough and gritty edge. They really have the classic tone- similar to an old Gretsch Hi-Lotron, but roughly 35% more output. Remember- we have the matching, calibrated, proportionally spaced Neck pickup as well.

These pickups sound AMAZING in a semi-hollow guitar. I've also installed them in a couple of solid bodies and they have a tremendous amount of edge, but with a full voice- substantially rounder than a Strat pickup, for instance. They clock in around 8.3K- that's PAF readings- so SUBSTANTIALLY more balls than a wimpy 5.2 vintage pickup!"

*****************************




Believe it.

Brother man, believe it.

Lord help me, I've heard the monstrous barking voice of the mother of all juice! These things are out-STANDING! The sound is meaty like a good 'bucker but with a big, round BOING in the sound like good single coil. There is plenty of bass, I hadda bring the bass down on a couple of amps where I've had Teles plugged in lately. Plenty of note distinction - every note has little barbs on the end - with hair on the barbs. Still they are plenty capable of being clear enough to be polite when necessary. Individual note identities remained copiously distinct not only during big power chords but even with extended jazz chords tastily overdriven. Adim7 will get muddy long before G major - but nobody got muddy here. It sounded big and pointed and juicy and ballsy and BAM and round through every amp I own. They seem to like the 500K volpot just fine.

The bridge pickup wasn't too trebly or harsh, even when playing leads around 12-15th positions. Even the lowest registers were not muddy through the neck pickup. "Big, open and airy, but with a tough and gritty edge." Straight up.

There isn't an amp in the house that didn't love these pickups - valve, SS, or hybrid.

Today this guitar makes a kind sound I've always tasted in the quiet corner of my soul and yearned to share. These don't sound ceramic to me, but GFS says they are. The sound is everything I've ever liked about a 'bucker and everything I've ever liked about a good Strat pup all rolled together into one perfectly balanced package....

and then slammed into my face on an 8 ft 2X10.


I like it.


The sound definately has a Gretsch flavor. It reminds me of some of the stuff my dad had when I was a kid, only now played through better amps.

Sixty bucks gets you a matched pair. You can barely buy ONE pickup from Seemore Duckbutt for that.... and his probably doesn't sound nearly this good. They seldom do.



Time will tell how I feel about these after the honeymoon is over.

Brooklyns in a Jet King. Coming soon to a gig near......uhhh....me.


*****************************

Teaser:

I did however, recently find a GFS pickup that I don't like. I bought a set (the model of which is to remain nameless for now) and really felt let down. They finally hit a strike with that model, and I'll give you the info soon. It hasn't soured my attitude about GFS, though. GFS has made me so happy so often that one strike doesn't shake my faith. That one strike sure as hell isn't the Brooklyn. The Brooklyn is a homer ......outta the park.

stingx
04-20-2006, 06:51 PM
Glad you posted this. I have recently ordered the Boutique PAFs in zebra from them. I cannot believe how cheap they were and how fast they got them out to me. I absolutely love them in my PT. I will post a pick of them when I get my camera back. They have been in the guitar for about 2 weeks now and I will definitely recommend GFS to anyone looking for pup replacement.

Cat
04-20-2006, 07:09 PM
Hey WNW how do ya reckon they would sound in a maple necked tele? Also, are they correct bucker size or do they need a pickup ring to mount them? GFS are a great company, thanks for the review brother.

Cat

Justpickin
04-20-2006, 07:14 PM
Sounds like you found a winning combo Ray!....I recently picked up a set of the GFS premium vintage pups for a white MIM strat I'm doing a do-over on, including all the electronics. Looking forward to hearing how those sound when I get them in.

WireNWood
04-20-2006, 09:05 PM
Hey WNW how do ya reckon they would sound in a maple necked tele?

This axe is alder, string-through, bolt-on - so the only difference between this and an alder Tele would be the maple. IMO: high probability of success (even with ash body- probably be awesome IMO).

They are straight-up humbucker sized. You could bolt them right into a pickguard instead of using the ring as long as your pickguard has a really rectangular hole, not very rounded on the corners. (I've had that problem before - I've learned to pay closer attention when veiwing pickguiards on eBay.)

Cat
04-20-2006, 09:55 PM
This axe is alder, string-through, bolt-on - so the only difference between this and an alder Tele would be the maple. IMO: high probability of success (even with ash body- probably be awesome IMO).

They are straight-up humbucker sized. You could bolt them right into a pickguard instead of using the ring as long as your pickguard has a really rectangular hole, not very rounded on the corners. (I've had that problem before - I've learned to pay closer attention when veiwing pickguiards on eBay.)
Haha cool man, Ive had that problem before.

Cat

ShineOn
04-20-2006, 10:18 PM
This thread kinda makes me want to go buy a used crappy guitar and replace the humbuckers with these.

Good write up :thumbsup:

Andoni
04-20-2006, 11:51 PM
Thanks WnW, GFS is one of the options that I'm looking at for the Squier 51, so many times I've read how people say how happy they are with theirs. So will have to try them, but not sure which ones yet.

WireNWood
04-21-2006, 12:31 AM
This thread kinda makes me want to go buy a used crappy guitar and replace the humbuckers with these.


Man, everybody should have at least one lab-rat hanging around.

Problem with the Jet King is it FEELS so good. I keep taking my lab rat to gigs and leaving much better-looking guitars at home.

I've pretty much decided that since it never was pretty and can never be pretty, I might as well go the other way with it - definitively. I'll be redoing it in a funky, roadworn motif with stickers/decals/logos/etc

anaheim flash
06-06-2006, 02:28 AM
and hey, what was the sour note GFS's? curious to know, now that i am an owner of one of their pups....